Join me in the cold, dark, life-sustaining NE Pacific Ocean to discover the great beauty, mystery and fragility hidden there.

Posts tagged ‘sea slug’

Nudibranch named for Dr. Sylvia Earle

I am very late to this party. Back in 2020, a nudibranch was named in honour of Dr. Sylvia Earle when there was reclassification of the Yellow-margin Dorid and the research was published by Korshunova et al.

There is now Sylvia Earle’s Cadlina (Cadlina sylviaearleae).  

Despite my great admiration for Dr. Earle and for sea slugs, I did not realize these two had come together until I recently posted one of the photos you see below. Karolle Wall very kindly let me know that this was no longer a Yellow-margin Dorid (Cadlina luteomarginata).



What follows is focused on the reclassification and how difficult it is to discern these species from external characteristics. If you have an electron microscope, it will be easier. 😉 You would be able to see the differences in the radula (tooth-like structures).

What was historically Cadlina luteomarginata is now at least four described “yellow-margin dorid” species. Sylvia Earle’s Cadalina is described as a sister species to Cadlina luteomarginata. What Karolle pointed out as a helpful discerning characteristic is the space between those distinctive tubercles on the nudibranch’s side.

From Korshunova et al., 2020
“Until recently, C. luteomarginata has been considered a single species with a whitish notum and yellow marginal line with a broad range in the north-eastern Pacific from Alaska to California (e.g. MacFarland, 1966; Behrens, 1991; Behrens & Hermosillo, 2005). Present integrative morphological and molecular analysis reveals that there is considerable hidden diversity among Cadlina from the north-eastern Pacific.”

Sylvia Earle’s Cadalina (Cadlina sylviaearleae)
“Opaque whitish, with some small dorsal tubercles tipped with yellow. Rhinophores with slight yellow tint. Gills are semitransparent white, similar to ground colour . . . differs both molecularly and in a number of morphological features from all other described Cadlina species.” (Korshunova et al., 2020).

Size to at least 2,5 cm. “Known from British Columbia to Oregon”. (Behrens et al., 2022)

Differences with the Yellow-margin Dorid (Cadlina luteomarginata) as originally described by MacFarland (1905, 1966)
“Considerably less tuberculated notum [upper surface of the body], more weakly developed yellow line around notum and by patterns of the radula”. (Korshunova et al., 2020).

Size up to 8.3 cm. “Species confirmed from British Columbia to Mendocino, California, possibly to Punta Eugenia, Baja California” (Behrens et al., 2022).



More from Nudibranchs and Sea Slugs of the Eastern Pacific, 2022:
“Recent molecular analysis work has revealed a number of cryptic species with the genus Cadlina. At least four species have been previously lumped under the name Cadlina luteomarginata and it is unclear at present whether these species can be reliably identified by their external characteristics . . . All are sponge predators.”


Personal note: Reading about these species and writing this blog took me over 3 hours. Why do this? Time evaporates and I get lost for a while in science and the sea. I suppose that’s enough reason. A great bonus would be if this is of use to others too.


Sources:

Behrens, David & Fletcher, Karin & Hermosillo, Alicia & Jensen, Gregory. (2022). Nudibranchs and Sea Slugs of the Eastern Pacific.

Behrens, David. (2022). Slug Site.

Korshunova, Tatiana & Fletcher, Karin & Picton, Bernard & Lundin, Kennet & Kashio, Sho & Sanamyan, Nadezhda & Sanamyan, Karen & Padula, Vinicius & Schroedl, Michael & Martynov, Alexander. (2020). The Emperor’s Cadlina, hidden diversity and gill cavity evolution: new insights for the taxonomy and phylogeny of dorid nudibranchs (Mollusca: Gastropoda). Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society. 10.1093/zoolinnean/zlz126.

Olson, Danielle (2025). Meet Sylvia Earle, the Trailblazing Marine Biologist Who Has Spent Her Career Giving Algae Their Long-Deserved Due. Smithsonian Magazine.

Who’s That (Yellow) Dorid

Yes, yes I do feel somehow better now that I have compiled the following for you. Thanks for asking.

Monterey Sea Lemons and Pacific Sea Lemons are commonly confused with one another (and other yellow dorid-like nudibranchs).

On a recent dive, I was able to get photos of the two species oriented the same way AND when their gills were not retracted! I hoped that by putting these photos side-by-side, it would be useful to others to identify the species.

The easiest differences to discern who is who, are the colour of the gills (yellow or white) and whether the black markings are at the tips of some of the tubercles or not.

I’ve added photos to show (1) their very different egg masses and (2) the variation of colour within the species.

You’re welcome. 💙


The Pacific Sea Lemon is also known as the Noble Sea Lemon.

The name of the Monterey Sea Lemon (aka Monterey Dorid) does not help with clearing up confusion as it is very commonly seen far to the north of Monterey.

Both eat sponges.

The following ranges for the species are as provided by Behrens et al, Nudibranchs & Sea Slugs of the Eastern Pacific:

  • Pacific Sea Lemon: Kodiak, Alaska to Punta Banta, Baja California
  • Monterey Sea Lemon: Kachemak Bay, Alaska to Punta Banta, Baja California

Yes, one day I will another blog discerning all the yellow dorid-like nudibranchs common to British Columbia e.g. Heath’s Dorid, Geitodoris heathi.


Photos: All taken around northeast Vancouver Island, Territory of the Kwakwa̱ka̱’wakw (the Kwak̕wala-speaking Peoples), ©Jackie Hildering.


More information:

Beautiful Berthella – a sea slug that is not a nudibranch

[Update! As a result of writing this blog, I learned that the species has been reclassified AGAIN. As of ~February 12, 2024, this is no longer Berthella chacei. It is now Boreoberthella chacei. I’ve updated the text below and will just reference the species as the “White Berthella”.]

There’s a whole lot of mating going on right now with the sea slug species, Boreoberthella chacei also known as “Chace’s Sidegill” and the “White Berthella”.

Two mating White Berthellas and an egg mass.

Not a nudibranch

The Berthella are examples of sea slugs that are NOT nudibranchs. I’ve emphasized previously that “nudibranch” is not synonymous with “sea slug”.

Dive buddy Jacqui Engel and White Berthellas laying egg masses / ribbons.


The nudibranchs are just one of the seven subgroups of sea slugs (the Heterobranchia). Thereby, all nudibranchs are sea slugs. But not all sea slugs are nudibranchs. I realize those two sentences may make your brain feel sluggish. Sorry / not sorry. 😉

Characteristics shared among nudibranchs are that they are sea slugs that all DO have naked gills on their backs (hence “nudi” and “branch”) and adults DON’T have an internal shell. 

Berthellas belong in a different group of sea slugs than nudibranchs. They are sidegill sea slugs (the Pleurobranchida order). They DON’T have naked gills and DO have an internal shell. The shell of White Berthellas is thin and white and is at least half the length of their bodies. Their gills, as the name “sidegill” suggests, extend from their side.

Specifically, the gills are on the right side, between the mantle and the foot. See them in the photo above?

Perspectives on the White Berthella that show how the rhinophores extend out from under the mantle. Rhinophores are the structures extending from a sea slug’s head that allow them to smell their way around. Berthella can retract these when there is an annoyance around. Yep, an annoyance like me. You can also see the beautiful “oral veil”.

Mating time

It’s typically in February and March that I see mating and egg masses for White Berthellas near northeast Vancouver Island.

Mating White Berthellas with egg masses.


I find it a marvel that they find one another. Throughout the rest of the year I see them quite spread out from one another. There can be some within a few metres of one another but with other sea slugs species, they are often within centimetres of one another.

With other sea slug species, Nature has ensured they are often very close by the species having VERY specific prey e.g. Pomegranate Aeolids ONLY feed on Raspberry Hydroids. Thereby, there are often others of your kind, nearby on this prey.

White Berthellas are reported to feed on sponges (specifically plakinid sponges like Slime Sponge, Oscarella carmela). They don’t seem to aggregate near these sponges, maybe because they are more diffuse? They must find one another by smell detected by their rhinophores and then crawl to be within proximity (this species does not swim).

When they find one another, they appear to jostle for position in aggregations. Pairing up right-side-to-right side means that they can attach by their “gonopores” and mating can occur. Both partners become inseminated and both will lay eggs. Like other sea slugs, they are simultaneous hermaphrodites. It makes a lot of sense when you are a sea slug to maximize how many eggs are laid, especially if your young hatch out to be part of the planktonic soup of the ocean. I believe that more than one egg mass is laid per parent.

Each dot you see in the photo is an egg capsule that is only ~1.6 mm long and it contains 1 or 2 fertilized eggs. Imagine how many fertilized eggs are in the egg masses in the photos below!



The veliger larvae hatch out at the age of around 18 days in 11 to 14 degrees Celcius (it would take longer around northeastern Vancouver Island where temperatures are colder). These larvae have eyespots and shells and are around 153 micrometer long; that’s 0.153 mm! (Goddard, 1984).

Reclassification

The White Berthellahas only been recognized as being a distinct species since 2020 (Ghanimi et al, 2020). It was thought that it was one of two “morphotypes” of the California Sidegill. As mentioned in the update at the top of this blog, very recently the species has been reclassified AGAIN. it is now Boreoberthella chacei.

The White Berthella (Boreoberthella chacei) is up to 7 cm long. The body is white and has little white bumps (tubercles) randomly distributed all over its body and rhinophores. Known range is Alaska south to San Diego, California and the Sea of Japan (Behrens et al., 2022)

The California Sidegill (now also reclassified as Boreoberthella californica) is bigger on average at up to 12.7 cm. Body is white to tan and is smooth. The little white dots are uniformly spread and are not on the rhinophores. Known range is Ventura County, California to the Pacific Coast of Panama and the Galapagos Islands (Behrens et al., 2022)

The egg masses of each sea slug species are distinct. As you can see below in the compilation from the research paper, this is the case for these two species of Berthella.

Side note: How it made me smile to see that my photo of White Berthella egg masses was referenced in the research paper discerning the two species!


Leather Star and Leafy Hornmouths (marine snails) near mating and egg-laying White Berthellas.

Sources:

More photos of White Berthellas mating, and their egg masses:

A White Berthella near a Blood Star.

Found! Cryptic Nudibranch

I finally observed some of the most cryptic nudibranchs on our coast! 💙

The Cryptic Nudibranchs you see here are only about 1 cm long and look at how astoundingly evolved they are! They are virtually invisible on the Kelp-encrusting Bryozoan which is growing on Bull Kelp at this time of year. This species of nudibranch is also known as Steinberg’s corambe (Corambe stinbergae to 1.7 cm).

You can see in the photos here that we found some of the nudibranchs mating and there were many of their egg ribbons (each of those coils has a lot of eggs that result from both parents becoming inseminated and laying eggs).

You can also see where they have been feeding on the bryozoans (colonies of animals).

I have looked for them for years knowing their range is from Alaska to Baja California, Mexico.

Mating: Right-side-to-right-side attached via the gonophores. Both hermaphrodite parents lay eggs.

What made the difference in now being able to find them:

(1) Getting the clue from Robin Agarwal to look at the kelp fronds that were REALLY tattered with the Kelp-encrusting Bryozoan colonies .

(2) Having a skilled dive buddy willing to join me in burying our heads in old, tattered kelp in the surge for 30 minutes instead of looking at all the big, colourful life at this dive site. Thank you Janice Crook!

(3) Once we knew what the egg ribbons looked like (those s-shaped little masses), we had a really good clue and knew better where to look even more closely for the nudibranchs.

Now on to finding the SECOND really cryptic nudibranch species that feeds on Kelp Encrusting Bryozoans – Corambe pacifica to 1.5 cm long and whose egg masses are tiny, flat coils.

For more photos and my previous blog on what Kelp-encrusting Bryozoans look like, please see my other blog “Kelp Lace? Bryozoans”.


Photos: September 19, 2022, Browning Pass ©Jackie Hildering, The Marine Detective.

Happy dive buddies
– Janice Crook and yours truly.

Eight Cryptic Nudibranchs, photo added September 2024.

Slugs that Fly? The Great Winged Sea Slug.

Here’s a species that deserves the descriptor “Great” without doubt – the GREAT Winged Sea Slug.

I will never forget the first time I saw one of these tiny sea slugs “flying” underwater.  My brain came close to exploding. I did not know of their existence prior to one flapping past my mask.

Dive buddy Natasha Dickinson pointing at a Great Winged Sea Slug.

Gastropteron pacificum is usually no bigger than your thumbnail. Maximum length is ~2 cm long and with “wingspan” to 4 cm. The species is also referenced as the Pacific Wingfoot Snail and the Pacific Batwing Sea Slug. But, as mentioned, I prefer the reference to their greatness.

Just marvel at how they can propel themselves, as captured in this video.

I will ALSO never forget the first time I saw them spawning, so many of them on the sandy ocean floor, their egg masses expanding to be bigger than they are.

I try to document this every year, looking in areas with sand in from late March into May. I have found them, and their eggs, as shallow as 2m depth.

And sure enough, on March 31st, there they were again. They are gathering to mate!

March 31, 2020 – “Beach Camp” near Port McNeill at only about 3m depth.

The photos below show you what the peak of the spawn looks like. Photos are from May 26th, 2019. Just look at the number of them! How do they find one another? How many eggs in an egg mass? So many questions!

I bet you also want to know how it can be that their masses of fertilized eggs are bigger than the sea slugs themselves. I presume the masses must expand with seawater but  .  . .  I do not know.

As is the case for most terrestrial and sea slugs, Great Winged Sea Slugs are simultaneous hermaphrodites whereby both parents become inseminated and lay eggs. It’s a great strategy to maximize chances of reproductive success when finding a mate is particularly challenging and your babies hatch into the planktonic soup of the ocean.

Among my many wonderings about this species is: Why have I never seen Great Winged Sea Slugs swimming during the time they are aggregating to mate?  I learned from research by Claudia Mills in Friday Harbour (published in 1994), that only sexually mature animals swim AND that they were only observed doing so between September and February i.e. not while mating.

Why swim? In may work well to escape annoying divers and/or bottom feeding fish like Ratfish. The timing suggests that it allows for population dispersal – spreading out for food and/or mates. You would think that the fact that hatch as plankton would spread them out enough. Also, HOW do they then assemble in numbers like this? Is it possible that these sea slugs smell one another’s scent trails even in the ocean?

You can see faint trails here.

Please know that this species IS a sea slug but it is NOT a nudibranch. Great Winged Sea Slugs don’t have naked gills and adults do have an internal shell when adults. Great Winged Sea Slugs belong to the group of sea slugs known as “bubble shells” of the order “Cephalaspidea”. You can even see the bubble shell in some of these images.  Ronald Shimek creatively described these sea slugs as having “an internal shell that looks quite like a soap bubble and is about as durable.”

The wing-like structures are called parapodia. When the sea slug is not swimming, these “wings” wrap around the body forming a water-filled cavity. See what looks like a siphon? Part of the “head-shied” folds into a siphon directing water into the cavity. There’s also an exhalant siphon.

The photo above is from the first time I ever noted this species. I was able to follow one as it drifted to the bottom and then saw the siphon appear. This added to the sensation that my brain was going to explode with awe. I shared the photos with experts and learned that, at that time (2007) it was not known what any members of the family feed upon. This added to my appreciation / understanding of how little is known about marine species that are even common and in the shallows. Bill Rudman responded with “I suspect they may feed on small flatworms or other invertebrate with no hard parts – but that is just a guess.” Apparently Gastopteron are known to feed on detritus and diatoms but it a laboratory setting, To my knowledge, there has not been confirmation of the diet of the species when in the wild.

More about the eggs via Jan Kocian: ”  Anne Hurst (1967) described the egg masses and veligers of Gastropteron pacificum. She considered the egg mass to be of “Type C,” that is, “in the form of an ovoid or globular jelly bag attached by a jelly string. Ths is common amongst cephalaspideans” (Hurst, 1967: 256). The egg mass of G. pacificum “is almost globular and of clear jelly. It contains widely separated rounded capsules containing spherical pink eggs. The smooth-walled capsules each have a short string-like protrusion from one point on their surfaces and this does not appear to be attached elsewhere. As the eggs develop to form a ball of cells, the pink colour becomes concentrated and at one side of it is a group of yellowish cells, the whole being surrounded by a narrow layer of greenish cells” (Hurst, 1967: 268) . .  . Egg capsule dimensions range from 181-220 µ, and the animals take 14-15 days to hatch.”

I hope, dear reader, that these words and images offer an additional chance to get lost in the natural world for a little bit. It offers me such comfort to see the steady flow of the natural world around me – from the courting of song birds, to the emergence of plants, and the mating of sea slugs.

Know that, right below the surface, there’s a world or greatness  .  .  . where slugs fly.


Note that if you see similar egg masses in the intertidal zone,I believe they are more likely to be from one of two other sea slug species that are also “bubble shell” sea slugs (order Cephalaspidea).

#1) Diomedes’ Aglaja (Melanochlamys diomedea to 1.5 cm long ): A fabulously wicked little sea slug that crawls under the sand looking for other sea slugs to snack on.

Diomedes’ Aglaja crawling through the sand in the shallows.
The black blob under the sand is a Diomedes’ Aglaja.Believe the blobs are this species egg masses.

#2) Spotted Aglaja (Aglaja ocelligera to 3 cm long): Usually also under the sand and prey to Diomedes’ Aglaja.

A rare good look at a Spotted Aglajid since they are usually burrowed in sand. Notice how one tail is longer than the other.
Two Spotted Aglajids above the sand, presumed one is following the other’s scent trail to get together to mate.
A Spotted Aglajid laying eggs! “Aglajids lay their eggs in the most interesting way. They release the egg stream around their rotating body, creating a coil or tube-like mass. They then dive into the sediment placing an anchor so the eggs, above, won’t wash away.” Source: Dave Behrens.

Sources:

For an additional blog about another bubble shell sea slug in the NE Pacific Ocean see – “Shelled Sea Slug! A small mystery solved.”


Classification of Sea Slugs 

My attempt at summarizing the cassification of the group to which sea slugs belong.
Last updated 2020-04-17. Source: World Register of Marine Species.

Regarding the photo below:
The Opalescent Nudibranch is a nudibranch.  Nudibranchs DO have external gills (hence “nudi” = naked and “branch” = gills). Adults do NOT have an internal shell.
The Great Winged Sea Slug is a “bubble shell” sea slug (Cephalaspidea). They do NOT have naked gills and adults DO have an internal shell.
There! Now don’t you feel better knowing that: (1) Not all sea slugs have naked gills and hence not all sea slugs are nudibranchs; (2) However, all nudibranchs are sea slugs.

Hooded Nudibranchs and their eggs

©Jackie Hildering
Hooded Nudibranchs – oral hood open ©Jackie Hildering

[Last updated on January 2, 2022]

The remarkable-looking animals to the right are Hooded Nudibranchs (Melibe leonina up to 17.5 cm). A nudibranch is subgrouping of sea slugs whose characteristics include having naked (“nudi”) gills (“branchs”).

Typically, starting in the fall, around northeast Vancouver Island, Hooded Nudibranchs come together in the hundreds. It is awe-inspiring to see them clustered together just below the surface, delicate and ghost-like, clinging to kelp. Most are translucent white but some individuals are more green or orange.

Often, you can see them swimming on the surface and many people mistake them for jellyfish. But no, they are sea slugs.


The large oral hood (disc-like head) is used to feed on plankton and small crustaceans. The lobed structures on the animals’ backs are the naked gills (cerata). The cerata can pop off if the Hooded Nudibranch is threatened e.g. pinched by a crab. This “ceretal autonomy” and the ability to swim, are believed to be distractors for predator (Bickell-Page, 1989).

The two structures on the Hooded Nudibranch’s oral hood are their rhinophores by which they smell their way around. Hooded Nudibranchs are believed to signal one another by emitting a fruity scent. My personal experience after having picked up a dead Hooded Nudibranch on the beach, is that the smell is something like a mix of watermelon and grapefruit. The scent stayed on my hand for more than an hour.

Hooded nudibranch swimming. ©Jackie Hildering
Hooded nudibranch swimming ©Jackie Hildering.

The secretion is reported to serve as a repellent for predators but does not deter Northern Kelp Crabs.

After mating, as is the way with sea slugs, both individuals lay eggs and then, they die. You can find additional information about sea slugs being reciprocal hermaphrodites in this past blog posting. 

Hooded Nudibranch eggs. ©Jackie Hildering
Hooded Nudibranch egg ribbons. ©Jackie Hildering

In the area around northeast Vancouver Island, I have observed that they lay their egg masses between January and April. Each ribbon of eggs is only about one centimetre wide. Every dot is an egg capsule containing 15 to 25 eggs. After about 10 days, depending on temperature, the eggs will hatch into larvae that will be part of the zooplankton soup of the Ocean.

After 1 to 2 months, they settle to the ocean bottom and change body shape and even digestive tract to become small adult Hooded Nudibranchs

Hooded Nudibranchs do not have the rasping mouth structure of many other sea slugs (the radula). They feed by opening their oral hood to capture prey while standing on kelp or Eelgrass.

Hooded Nudibranch on Eelgrass and yes, those little snails are part of their diet.


From Invertebrates of the Salish Sea: ” . . . diet includes copepods, amphipods, and ostracods, as well as small post-larval mollusks.  The animal stands attached to the substrate and expands the oral hood.  It then sweeps the hood left and right or downward. When the ventral surface of the hood contacts a small animal the hood rapidly closes and the fringing tentacles overlap, holding the prey in.  The whole animal is then forced into the nudibranch’s mouth.”

Hooded Nudibranchs on Giant Kelp. ©Jackie Hildering, 2022

For more information:

Biodiversity of the Central Coast: Hooded Nudibranch

Deep Sea News: “This sea slug is like a cross between a dinosaur, a jellyfish, and a watermelon”

Lawrence, K. A. and Winsor H Watson. “Earth , Oceans , and Space ( EOS ) 10-1-2002 Swimming Behavior of the Nudibranch Melibe leonina.” (2017).

Newcomb, James M., et al. “Homology and Homoplasy of Swimming Behaviors and Neural Circuits in the Nudipleura (Mollusca, Gastropoda, Opisthobranchia).” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 109, National Academy of Sciences, 2012, pp. 10669–76, http://www.jstor.org/stable/41601654.

100s of Hooded Nudibranchs just below the surface in Telegraph Cove ©Jackie Hildering.

Dive buddy Jacqui Engel with Hooded Nudibranch ©Jackie Hildering.